What is it like to engage in talks with Russian representatives concerning the conflict in Ukraine?
This question has generated considerable interest in the wake of multiple recent sessions of ceasefire talks, which until now seemed to yield minimal fruit four years after Russia's comprehensive military offensive.
Another round of American-facilitated negotiations is expected to occur in Geneva later this week. In preparation, an important member of Ukrainian President Zelensky's negotiating team, Sergiy Kyslytsya, who has taken part in the latest direct military discussions, has provided his viewpoint.
According to Kyslytsya, these interactions are professional and generally free of the type of ideological and rhetorical posturing seen elsewhere by Russian leadership.
"The military possess a superior understanding of what is going on in the combat zone," he remarked in a meeting earlier this week.
"The question remains whether they [the Russians] are able, or not, of reporting [back] accurately…free from cooking or changing the information," he added.
It is far from an easy thing to attempt to halt a major conflict. The nature of the battlefield in the Donbas region - where thousands of drones operate and kill over a vast so-called "grey zone" between the opposing forces, while two hundred thousand local civilians still live in the "fortress belt" urban areas of the Donbas - makes the technical process of separation highly complex.
"It is essential to have a clear framework of rules and procedures," the diplomat explained, "along with a way to verify and monitor."
The Role of External Mediators
Much of these preparations, he noted, is finished, partly due to the close participation of US officials, such as General Alexus Grynkewich and a high-ranking Army official.
Clearly not in Kyiv's interest to disparage representatives of the American administration, but when Kyslytsya praises the American team for its efforts, he comes across as genuine.
"We must credit the Americans for their dedication and their perseverance," he states, "because they attend the meetings non-stop. They don't only watch…they ask questions and they heed our answers."
Kyslytsya was equally positive about the roles of the former president's adviser, whom he described as "not a novice", and billionaire mediator Steve Witkoff, whom he described as "far more astute individual than the caricature portrayal you see in the media".
The United States, he asserted, will undertake a critical role in monitoring any future ceasefire, with capabilities including satellite and other types of high-tech monitoring.
"It is necessary to have an entity who will play the role of adjudication, because if there is a breach there must be a neutral actor that is reliable [and] authoritative."
Past and Present Monitoring Challenges
For eight years before the full-scale offensive in recent years, this oversight function was played by the OSCE - a group whose limited means and lack of enforcement mechanisms rendered it mostly incapable of averting an escalation.
"That was quite an achievement [for them] just to operate two drones flying over the area," Kyslytsya commented. "It resembles the Flintstones period in contrast with what we have today."
By contrast, recent reports indicate that up to 12,000 unmanned aircraft are active over the urban center of Pokrovsk at any given moment.
An Insider's Account on Confronting the Opposition
Inquired about his ability to sit across the table from delegates from a head of state in the Russian government who has shown readiness to expend over a million of his own men to conquer its neighbor, Kyslytsya, with extensive UN experience, offered his answer.
He told that he'd had a long time of experience.
"I witnessed far more difficult situations. I spent five years in New York, a portion prior to the major war. I would sit in the room with the enemy on a regular basis."
One evening is seared in his memory: 23 February 2022.
During an urgent UN Security Council meeting, convened to discuss the urgent crisis in the country, the ambassador received news that his homeland was being assaulted.
At the same time, far away to the eastward in Kyiv, initial distant explosions were heard as the total attack on the nation began.
Amid moments of intense drama, Kyslytsya tried to persuade Russia's ambassador, Vassily Nebenzia, to call his boss, Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, to obtain guarantees that Russian forces would not cross the border.
"I've already said everything that I am aware of now," Nebenzia responded, according to his Ukrainian colleague. "I will not wake Minister Lavrov at this time."
Everyone's lives changed at that instant. Kyslytsya remained at the UN for another three years before returning to Kyiv.
The Path Forward
Should the negotiating teams meet again in Geneva on Thursday, he'll be there, still thrashing out the details and mechanics of a halt in fighting but waiting all the while for the most important element of the jigsaw to fall into place.
"The war might be ended by simply a single order of an individual to his top general," he said.
"However, the Russian president [Vladimir Putin] is not up to stopping the war for the time being."